PanicStation.org
UK USA
us Death, bereavement & serious family crises

What to do if…
family members are giving doctors conflicting instructions during an end-of-life situation

Produced and maintained by PanicStation.org Published: Last reviewed: Editorial policy USA guide

Short answer

Ask the clinician responsible for care, or in a hospital the attending physician or charge nurse, to clarify whether the patient can make or participate in the urgent decisions. Ask the team to identify any document guiding care, say who it is treating as the decision-maker, and use one main family contact for updates where appropriate.

Do not do these things

  • Do not try to settle urgent treatment decisions by a family vote at the bedside.
  • Do not speak over the patient. Even if the patient’s decision-making capacity is impaired, ask the team how the patient can still be involved.
  • Do not give the care team repeated, conflicting requests through several relatives. Ask for one main family contact and one backup where appropriate.
  • Do not assume that one relative automatically has authority to decide. Ask the team to check any documents, state law, and the care provider’s policy.
  • Do not assume every requested treatment must be provided. Ask the team to explain the options, the limits, and any review process.
  • Do not threaten staff, block care, or post private medical details publicly.

What to do now

  1. Ask the clinician responsible for care to clarify the immediate decision-making process.
    In a hospital, ask the attending physician or charge nurse. Say: “Please tell us whether the patient can make or participate in the urgent decisions, whether any advance directive, named health care agent, or portable medical order is available, and who the team is treating as the decision-maker.”

  2. Ask which decisions cannot wait.
    Ask the team to separate urgent decisions from decisions that can be discussed later. Ask it to explain the current care plan and any current orders in plain language.

  3. Bring or securely send any available documents.
    Look for:

    • an advance directive or living will,
    • a durable power of attorney for health care or health care proxy document,
    • a POLST form or another portable medical-order form used in the state.
      Ask how to add any documents to the care record.

  4. Ask for a prompt discussion with the care team.
    Ask whether a care conference can be arranged as soon as available. Ask for the clinician responsible for care and, where appropriate, a nurse, social worker, case manager, or palliative-care clinician to be involved.
    Say: “We are giving different messages. Please help us clarify the patient’s wishes, the person the team is using for decisions, the current plan, and what remains unresolved.”

  5. Ask for one main communications pathway.
    Where appropriate, ask the team to use one main family contact and one backup for routine updates. Ask how that arrangement should be recorded and how other relatives can receive updates without sending separate instructions. This does not replace the patient’s direct involvement when the patient can participate.

  6. Ask whether an ethics consultation is available if disagreement continues.
    Say: “Is an ethics consultation or another institutional resource available to help with disagreement about the appropriate decision-maker or the treatment plan?”

  7. If the patient is in a hospital and messages are still getting crossed, ask for the hospital’s communication or grievance contact.
    Ask how to reach Patient Relations, the patient representative, or the hospital grievance contact. Ask for help arranging a clear discussion and recording the communications pathway. In another care setting, ask which communication or complaint contact is available.

  8. If no decision-maker is clearly identified and a decision is urgent, ask the care team to explain its local process.
    Say: “What process do you use under applicable law and policy when an urgent decision is needed and the appropriate decision-maker is unclear?”

What can wait

  • You do not need to resolve old family conflicts or decide who is to blame now.
  • You do not need to decide whether to make a formal complaint or seek legal advice during the immediate discussion.
  • You do not need to post updates publicly or answer every message from relatives immediately.
  • You do not need to make inheritance, funeral, or long-term financial decisions during the acute medical crisis.

Important reassurance

A clear process can reduce crossed messages even when family members do not agree immediately. The immediate goal is to keep the patient’s wishes central, identify which decisions cannot wait, and make communication calmer and clearer.

Scope note

These are first steps for the immediate situation. Later decisions may need state-specific medical, legal, or other specialist help.

Important note

This is general information, not medical, legal, financial, therapeutic, or other professional advice. State law, care-provider policy, the patient’s condition, and the available documents can affect the process. If confusion is delaying an urgent decision, ask for the clinician responsible for care immediately. In a hospital, ask for the charge nurse and attending physician.

Additional Resources

Closely connected guides that may be useful during the same situation or its immediate aftermath.

About this guide

This guide was produced and is maintained by PanicStation.org using its published editorial process. Official and specialist sources are checked where relevant, and AI-assisted tools may be used for drafting, organisation, and consistency checks. The site operator remains responsible for publication, revision, and removal decisions.

Support us